Common Mechanical Failures That Cause Accidents
Tire blowouts, brake failures, steering system defects, faulty airbags, and accelerator malfunctions can all cause drivers to lose control. These failures are especially dangerous at highway speeds on roads like I-70, I-71, and the I-270 outerbelt surrounding Columbus.
In many cases, the vehicle owner has no warning that a critical component is about to fail. Defective design, manufacturing errors, or substandard repair work by a mechanic may be the root cause of the malfunction.
Product liability for defective vehicle components
Product Liability and Negligent Maintenance
Ohio product liability law (O.R.C. § 2307.71 et seq.) allows injury victims to sue manufacturers, distributors, and retailers of defective vehicle components. You may pursue a claim based on a design defect, manufacturing defect, or failure to warn about a known risk.
If a mechanic or repair shop performed negligent work — such as improperly installing brakes or failing to tighten lug nuts — they can be held liable under a negligence theory. Maintenance records and repair shop invoices become essential evidence in these cases.
75+
Years of combined legal experience
$0
Upfront cost to you — we work on contingency
Our attorneys have the trial experience and resources to take on insurance companies and corporate defendants. You pay nothing unless we win your case.
Investigating Mechanical Failure Claims
Mechanical failure cases require prompt investigation because the vehicle itself is the primary evidence. Babin Law works with automotive engineers and accident reconstruction experts to examine the vehicle, identify the failed component, and determine whether defective design, manufacturing, or maintenance caused the failure.
If you suspect a mechanical failure contributed to your accident, do not allow the vehicle to be repaired or scrapped before consulting an attorney. Preserving the vehicle is critical to building a successful claim.
What to Do After a Mechanical Failure Accident in Ohio
When a vehicle component fails and causes a crash, the vehicle itself is the most critical piece of evidence. Preserving it — and acting quickly — can mean the difference between a successful claim and one that cannot be proven.
Get to Safety and Call 911
After a mechanical failure — tire blowout, brake failure, steering loss — your immediate priority is safety. Pull over if possible, activate hazard lights, and call 911. Report to the responding officers exactly what happened before the crash: 'My brakes stopped working,' 'The tire blew out,' or 'The steering locked up.' This statement goes into the police report as critical evidence.
Do NOT Repair or Dispose of the Vehicle
This is the single most important step. Do not authorize any repairs, and do not allow the vehicle to be scrapped or sold for salvage. The failed component — the tire, brake assembly, steering mechanism, or airbag system — is the primary evidence in your case. Inform the tow company and your insurance company that the vehicle must be preserved in its post-accident condition.
Photograph the Vehicle and Failed Component
Take detailed photographs of the vehicle from every angle, focusing on the area of mechanical failure. Photograph the tires (including tread depth and sidewall condition), brake components, steering linkage, or whatever part you believe failed. Document the accident scene, skid marks, and debris. These photos preserve evidence of the failure in its immediate aftermath.
Gather Maintenance and Repair Records
Collect all records of vehicle maintenance, repairs, tire rotations, brake work, and inspections. If a repair shop recently worked on the component that failed, their records may show negligent workmanship. If the vehicle is still under manufacturer warranty, warranty records and recall notices are relevant. These documents establish the maintenance history and help identify whether a mechanic, manufacturer, or parts supplier is liable.
Check for Recalls and Safety Bulletins
Search the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) database at recalls.gov for recalls or safety bulletins related to your vehicle's make, model, and year. If the failed component is subject to an active recall, this strengthens your product liability claim significantly. Even Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs) that fall short of a formal recall can indicate known defects.
Contact a Mechanical Failure Attorney Before the Evidence Disappears
Mechanical failure cases require expert analysis of the failed vehicle component. An attorney can send a spoliation preservation letter to insurance companies, repair shops, and tow yards to prevent the vehicle from being destroyed. Babin Law works with automotive engineers and accident reconstruction experts to investigate failure causes.
What Is Your Mechanical Failure Case Worth?
Mechanical failure accident claims may involve product liability against manufacturers or negligence against repair shops. These cases can produce substantial compensation because corporate defendants with deep pockets are often involved.
Severity of Injuries From the Accident
Mechanical failures at highway speeds — tire blowouts on I-70, brake failures approaching I-270 interchanges — cause violent, high-speed crashes with severe injuries. Traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord damage, multiple fractures, and fatalities are common outcomes. The severity of your injuries drives the compensatory damage calculation.
Type of Defect (Design, Manufacturing, or Warning)
Ohio product liability law (O.R.C. § 2307.71 et seq.) recognizes three types of defects: design defects (the product is inherently dangerous), manufacturing defects (the specific unit was improperly made), and failure to warn (inadequate safety warnings or instructions). Design and manufacturing defects involving widely sold components may affect thousands of vehicles, giving manufacturers strong incentive to settle.
Identity of the Liable Party
Mechanical failure claims may target vehicle manufacturers, component manufacturers, parts distributors, repair shops, and maintenance providers. Corporate defendants like major automakers and tire manufacturers carry substantial insurance and have significant assets. The financial capacity of the defendant directly affects the recoverable compensation.
Evidence of Prior Knowledge or Recalls
If the manufacturer knew about the defect — through internal testing, prior complaints, NHTSA investigations, or recalls — and failed to adequately address it, this strengthens your claim and may support punitive damages. Evidence that a company prioritized profits over safety resonates powerfully with Ohio juries.
Negligent Repair or Maintenance
If a mechanic or repair shop performed substandard work — improperly installing brakes, using wrong parts, failing to torque lug nuts, or ignoring manufacturer specifications — they may be liable for the resulting accident. Repair shop negligence claims are straightforward to prove when maintenance records show recent work on the component that failed.
Vehicle preservation is non-negotiable in mechanical failure cases. Once the vehicle is repaired, scrapped, or sold, the physical evidence needed to prove the defect may be permanently lost.
Babin Law retains automotive engineers and accident reconstruction specialists to investigate mechanical failures and identify every liable party. Contact us for a free case evaluation if you believe a vehicle defect caused your accident.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mechanical Failure
Get answers to the questions our Columbus attorneys hear most from clients in mechanical failure cases.
Have a question not answered here?
Every case is unique. Our attorneys can answer your specific questions during a free, confidential consultation.
Ask Us DirectlyReady to Discuss Your Case?
Free consultations. No fees unless we win.
